EN | UA
EN | UA

Help Support

Back

Does dose adjustment or therapy switching boost smoking cessation success?

Smoking cessation Smoking cessation
Smoking cessation Smoking cessation

What's new?

For smokers who fail their first quit attempt, increasing the dosage of varenicline or CNRT—or switching CNRT to varenicline—markedly improves short-term and 6-month abstinence rates.

Most smokers do not achieve abstinence on their first quit attempt, but a recent study issued in "JAMA" identifies effective follow-up strategies for those who fail initial treatment. Conducted at a Texas tobacco treatment clinic, this randomized clinical trial enrolled 490 adult smokers (210 women, 287 non-Hispanic White, mean age 48.1 years) who smoked an average of 20 cigarettes per day.

Participants were first treated with either varenicline, a prescription smoking cessation medication, or combined nicotine replacement therapy (CNRT), consisting of a 21-mg patch plus 2-mg lozenges. Those who did not achieve smoking cessation at the 6-week mark were randomly allocated again to continue the same regimen, transition to another therapy, or increase their medication dose for the next 6 weeks. All the subjects received weekly brief counseling throughout the study.

(a) Results for CNRT volunteers:

Of 245 CNRT volunteers, 54 achieved abstinence after the first 6 weeks and continued therapy.

  • Among the 191 nonabstainers, 151 were rerandomized; 40 who did not return continued their original CNRT regimen.
  • End-of-treatment abstinence among the 191 phase 1 nonabstainers:
    1. Continued CNRT at same dose: 8% (95% credible interval [CrI], 6%–10%)
    2. Increased CNRT dosage: 14% (95% CrI, 10%–18%)
    3. Switched to varenicline: 14% (95% CrI, 10%–18%)
  • Absolute risk difference (RD) for increased dose or switch vs continuation: 6% (95% CrI, 6%–11%)
  • Probability that either strategy was superior to continuation: >99%

(b) Results for varenicline volunteers:

  • Of 210 varenicline participants, 88 achieved abstinence after 6 weeks and continued therapy.
  • Among 157 nonabstainers, 122 were rerandomized; 35 who did not return continued initial therapy.
  • End-of-treatment abstinence among phase 1 nonabstainers:
    1. Increased varenicline dosage: 20% (95% CrI, 16%–26%)
    2. Switched to CNRT: 0% (95% CrI, 0%–0%)
    3. Continued varenicline at initial dose: 3% (95% CrI, 1%–4%)
  • Absolute RD for continuing vs increasing dosage: -3% (95% CrI, -4% to -1%), with >99% posterior probability that continuing at the same dose was worse.
  • Raising varenicline dosage exhibited an absolute RD of 18% (95% CrI, 13%–24%) with >99% posterior probability of benefit.

(c) 6-Month Continuous Abstinence:

  • Only those who increased dosages of CNRT or varenicline showed a prominent benefit when compared with continuing the initial doses.

To sum up, for smokers who do not achieve abstinence after 6 weeks of treatment, tailored adjustments boost success. Nonabstainers initially on CNRT benefit from either a dosage increase or switching to varenicline, while those on varenicline benefit most from escalating the dosage rather than switching therapies. These findings yield clear guidance for clinicians seeking effective rescue strategies for smokers struggling to quit.

Source:

JAMA

Article:

Smoking Cessation After Initial Treatment Failure With Varenicline or Nicotine Replacement: A Randomized Clinical Trial

Authors:

Paul M Cinciripini et al.

Comments (0)

You want to delete this comment? Please mention comment Invalid Text Content Text Content cannot me more than 1000 Something Went Wrong Cancel Confirm Confirm Delete Hide Replies View Replies View Replies en ru
Try: